What Is True About Investing in Single Stocks? Understanding the Risks and Rewards
Imagine investing a significant portion of your savings in a single company's stock, confident in its future success. While that confidence can be rewarded, it can also come with meaningful risks. Understanding what is true about investing in single stocks involves weighing the potential rewards against factors such as market volatility, concentration risk, and the emotional challenges of decision-making.
By understanding the potential risks and rewards, investors may be better positioned to wisely steward their resources and make more informed decisions with their finances.
At Cooke Wealth Management, we aim to help clients wisely navigate investing with clarity and discipline. By aligning investment choices with long-term financial goals, we work to help ensure each decision supports a more thoughtful, strategic, personalized strategy. By understanding the distinctions between investing and speculating, investors may be better positioned to wisely steward their resources and make more informed decisions.
The Allure of Single-Stock Investing
Investing in individual stocks can be appealing. The idea of identifying a promising company early and potentially benefiting from its success captures the imagination, especially when stories about early investors in tech giants like Apple or Nvidia make headlines. But while the upside can be meaningful, so can the risks.
Potential for High Returns
One of the most compelling reasons investors choose individual stocks is the opportunity for outsized gains. Unlike mutual funds or ETFs, which offer broad exposure across many companies, a single stock gives you direct ownership in one business. If that business performs well, the return can exceed what more diversified investments may deliver.
However, the reverse is also true. If the company struggles or fails, the value of your investment may decline significantly. Even seasoned investors have failed to consistently predict how individual companies will perform over time.
Consider an investor who purchased shares in a promising startup five years ago. If the company experienced rapid growth—perhaps going public or expanding its market share—the value of that investment may have increased significantly.
While this scenario illustrates the potential for strong returns, it’s important to recognize that individual stocks can also be highly volatile. Just as gains can be amplified, poor performance may result in substantial losses. Unlike broadly diversified investments, single-stock positions carry concentrated risk that can impact an investor’s portfolio more significantly.
Control and Transparency
Single-stock investing can offer more control and transparency than pooled investment products. You know exactly what you own, and you can make buy or sell decisions based on your own research or convictions. This may appeal to investors with specific knowledge of a sector or industry.
Additionally, some investors appreciate being able to follow a company closely—reading earnings reports, listening to analyst calls, and staying informed about developments that may affect its performance. However, this level of involvement requires time, discipline, and a tolerance for market fluctuations.
Tax Efficiency
Owning individual stocks may offer more flexibility when managing taxes. You can choose when to realize capital gains, which can support strategies like tax-loss harvesting, which, for some investors, can be particularly useful toward the end of the year.
In contrast, mutual fund investors may distribute capital gains to all investors based on the fund’s internal activity, regardless of whether you’ve sold your shares. With single stocks, investors typically avoid unexpected taxable distributions, though it’s always wise to consult a tax professional when planning around investment decisions.
The Role of Diversification
While single stocks may play a role in your overall portfolio, relying too heavily on one company can expose you to unnecessary risk. After all, you need to know when to get in and when to get out, before everyone else does. Diversification—spreading investments across different sectors, asset classes, or geographic regions—may help reduce the impact of any single holding’s performance.
Companies that once dominated an industry can change with time. It can often be beneficial to explore the role of diversification and determine when individual stocks may or may not fit into a broader investment strategy.
Market Volatility and Timing
Individual stocks tend to experience greater price swings (higher highs and lower lows) than diversified investments. Their values can fluctuate based on individual company news and economic or market news.
Things like earnings, analyst ratings, market sentiment, macroeconomic news, policy changes, or even unexpected leadership changes can have an impact on prices. This volatility can make it difficult to time entry or exit points effectively.
When it comes time to need your money, the last thing you want is for the money not to be there.
Many investors unintentionally react to emotional cues—buying when prices are high due to excitement, and selling when prices drop out of fear. This behavior can erode returns over time or result in losses. Even professional investors often find it challenging to consistently time the market, and with individual stocks, the margin for error can be narrower.
While recent markets have reminded us, the bible has long before reinforced that cycles are inevitable and normal (2 Peter 3:4). As investors, the question is often how we should respond when it does happen, or in some cases, what can we do to preserve or protect against it.
Emotional Decision-Making
Investing isn’t purely logical—emotions often influence decision-making. Single stocks, which can swing sharply in value, may heighten emotional reactions such as fear and greed. A moderate dip in a diversified fund might seem manageable, but a sharp drop in a single stock could lead to panic.
Behavioral biases—like overconfidence, confirmation bias, or loss aversion—can lead investors to hold onto struggling positions too long or chase trends without understanding the fundamentals. A well-defined strategy and long-term focus may help reduce emotional missteps and promote healthier financial habits over time.
Diversification: A Key Strategy
Diversification is often an effective tool available to help manage investment risk. By spreading investments across a variety of companies, sectors, and asset types, investors may reduce the impact of poor performance from any single investment or area of the market.
Potential Benefits of Diversification
A diversified portfolio may help smooth out returns and reduce volatility. If one stock or sector underperforms, others may perform differently, helping to offset losses. Diversification can also allow investors to stay more focused on long-term goals and be less influenced by short-term fluctuations.
Diversification can also reduce the temptation to constantly react to short-term market movements or noise. With broader exposure, investors may be more likely to stay committed to a long-term strategy rather than chase performance.
Implementation
There are many ways to diversify. Investors can include a mix of domestic and international stocks, bonds, real estate, and alternative assets. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and low-cost index funds are often popular tools for broad exposure. Even within the equity portion of a portfolio, spreading investments across various sizes or industries—such as healthcare, technology, and consumer goods—may provide additional balance.
For investors who still wish to include individual stocks, doing so within a diversified framework may help reduce risk. A common approach is to limit individual stock positions to a modest percentage of the total portfolio—often 5–10%—while maintaining broad market exposure elsewhere.
Aligning Investments with Personal Goals and Values
Successful investing is about more than just numbers. It begins with understanding your goals and what matters most to you —what you want your money to achieve, both practically and personally.
Understanding Your Financial Objectives
Your investments should be tied to your goals—whether that’s saving for retirement, funding a child’s education, or creating a legacy. Defining short- and long-term objectives can help guide more consistent, informed decisions.
Risk Tolerance Assessment
Every investor’s comfort with risk is different. While some are comfortable with short-term swings in value, others prefer a more stable experience. Individual stocks can be unpredictable, so knowing your personal risk tolerance may help you avoid decisions you’ll later regret during periods of volatility.
Values-Based Investing
For many investors, aligning financial decisions with personal or ethical values is just as important as achieving returns. Values-based investing may involve avoiding certain industries or focusing on companies with strong environmental, social, or governance (ESG) practices. This approach can offer peace of mind and may help strengthen long-term commitment to a strategy.
The Role of Professional Guidance
Investing in the stock market can be complex and often requires ongoing monitoring, discipline, and expertise. That’s where a trusted financial advisor can help.
Customized Financial Planning
No two investors are alike. An advisor can help develop a personalized strategy that reflects your goals, risk tolerance, and tax situation, while placing single-stock decisions within the larger context of your financial plan.
Ongoing Support and Monitoring
Markets evolve, and so do your needs. Advisors often provide regular reviews and adjustments, helping you stay aligned with your goals through life changes like career transitions, loss of a loved one, or retirement. Proactive oversight may help prevent common mistakes and support better outcomes over time.
Experienced Guidance and Education
Advisors can do more than manage assets—they can educate, explain market dynamics, and offer objective insights during emotional or uncertain times. They can help you consider your options and identify the ideal one for you. Their experience can be a valuable asset in helping you stay focused on strategy, not headlines.
Smart Strategy Starts with the Right Support
When evaluating what is true about investing in single stocks, it’s clear that the potential for reward exists, but so do meaningful risks. Diversification remains a foundational strategy for managing uncertainty, and thoughtful planning is essential.
At Cooke Wealth Management, we work with clients to design strategies that reflect their unique situation and goals. If you're considering or currently investing in individual stocks, we invite you to connect with us. Let’s build a plan that’s clear, balanced, and built to grow with you.
Start a Conversation with Cooke Wealth Management
FAQs
1. Is it smart to invest in individual stocks?
It depends on your goals and risk tolerance, and overall financial strategy. While individual stocks may offer potential for growth, they can also involve higher risk.
2. Can single-stock investing ever make sense?
Yes, in certain cases. We’ve all heard the stories of people who guessed right. For some investors, the risks are worth it, for some it’s not, and for others, individual stocks can complement a diversified portfolio. Either way, it’s generally wise to limit exposure and avoid using funds that are essential to your financial security..
3. How does single-stock investing impact taxes?
Owning individual stocks may provide more control over when gains are realized. Still, careful planning is important to avoid unexpected tax consequences. A financial advisor or tax professional can help guide these decisions.
4. Should I work with an advisor when investing in single stocks?
Working with an advisor can be beneficial. A trusted professional can help evaluate whether single-stock investments make sense within your broader goals and help you avoid common behavioral and strategic pitfalls. When done right, they can often help you invest with purpose and confidence..
*We recommend that you consult a tax or financial advisor about your individual situation.